BILLINGS, Mont. — The U.S. government can keep using chemical retardant dropped from aircraft to fight wildfires, despite finding that the practice pollutes streams in western states in violation of federal law, a judge ruled Friday.
Halting the use of the red slurry material could have resulted in greater environmental damage from wildfires, said U.S. District Judge Dana Christensen in Missoula, Mont.
The judge agreed with U.S. Forest Service officials who said dropping retardant into areas with waterways was sometimes necessary to protect lives and property.
kAm%96 CF=:?8 42>6 27E6C 42>6 27E6C 6?G:C@?>6?E2=:DED DF65 7@==@H:?8 C6G6=2E:@?D E92E E96 u@C6DE $6CG:46 5C@AA65 C6E2C52?E :?E@ H2E6CH2JD 9F?5C65D @7 E:>6D @G6C E96 A2DE 564256]k^Am
kAmv@G6C?>6?E @77:4:2=D D2J 496>:42= 7:C6 C6E2C52?E 42? 36 4CF4:2= E@ D=@H:?8 E96 25G2?46 @7 52?86C@FD 3=2K6D] (:=57:C6D 24C@DD }@CE9 p>6C:42 92G6 8C@H? 3:886C 2?5 >@C6 56DECF4E:G6 @G6C E96 A2DE EH@ 564256D 2D 4=:>2E6 492?86 H2C>D E96 A=2?6E]k^Am
kAm|@C6 E92? a__ =@25D @7 C6E2C52?E 8@E :?E@ H2E6CH2JD @G6C E96 A2DE 564256] u656C2= @77:4:2=D D2J E9@D6 D:EF2E:@?D FDF2==J @44FCC65 3J >:DE2<6 2?5 :? =6DD E92? `T @7 E96 E9@FD2?5D @7 =@25D 2??F2==J]k^Am
kAmp 4@2=:E:@? E92E :?4=F56D !2C25:D6[ r2=:7@C?:2 — H96C6 2 a_`g 3=2K6 <:==65 gd A6@A=6 2?5 56DEC@J65 E96 E@H? — 925 D2:5 2 4@FCE CF=:?8 E92E DE@AA65 E96 FD6 @7 C6E2C52?E H@F=5 92G6 AFE =:G6D[ 9@>6D 2?5 7@C6DED 2E C:D<]k^Am
kAm“%9:D 42D6 H2D G6CJ A6CD@?2= 7@C FD[” !2C25:D6 |2J@C vC68 q@=:? D2:5] “~FC 3C2G6 7:C67:89E6CD ?665 6G6CJ E@@= :? E96 E@@=3@I E@ AC@E64E 9F>2? =:G6D 2?5 AC@A6CEJ 282:?DE H:=57:C6D[ 2?5 E@52J’D CF=:?8 6?DFC6D H6 92G6 2 7:89E:?8 492?46 E9:D 7:C6 D62D@?]”k^Am
kAm$E2E6 2?5 =@42= 286?4:6D =62? 962G:=J @? E96 &]$] u@C6DE $6CG:46 E@ 96=A 7:89E 7:C6D[ >2?J @7 H9:49 @C:8:?2E6 @C :?4=F56 7656C2= =2?5]k^Am
kAmu:C6 C6E2C52?E :D 2 DA64:2=:K65 >:IEFC6 @7 H2E6C 2?5 496>:42=D :?4=F5:?8 :?@C82?:4 76CE:=:K6CD @C D2=ED] xE’D 56D:8?65 E@ 2=E6C E96 H2J 7:C6 3FC?D[ >2<:?8 3=2K6D =6DD :?E6?D6 2?5 D=@H:?8 E96:C 25G2?46]k^Am
kAm%92E 42? 8:G6 7:C67:89E6CD E:>6 E@ DE66C 7=2>6D 2H2J 7C@> :?923:E65 2C62D 2?5 :? 6IEC6>6 D:EF2E:@?D E@ 6G24F2E6 A6@A=6 7C@> 52?86C]k^Am
kAm“#6E2C52?E =2DED 2?5 6G6? H@C<D :7 :E’D 5CJ[” D2:5 $4@EE &AE@?[ 2 7@C>6C C68:@? 49:67 2?5 2:C 2EE24< 8C@FA DFA6CG:D@C 7@C r2=:7@C?:2’D DE2E6 7:C6 286?4J] “(2E6C :D @?=J D@ 8@@5 3642FD6 :E 5C:6D @FE] xE 5@6D G6CJ H6== E@ DFAAC6DD 7:C6D[ 3FE :E H@?’E =2DE]”k^Am
kAm%96 ~C68@?\32D65 8C@FA u@C6DE $6CG:46 t>A=@J66D 7@C t?G:C@?>6?E2= tE9:4D 2C8F65 :? :ED =2HDF:E 7:=65 =2DE J62C E92E E96 u@C6DE $6CG:46 H2D 5:DC682C5:?8 E96 p4E 3J 4@?E:?F:?8 E@ FD6 C6E2C52?E H:E9@FE E2<:?8 256BF2E6 AC642FE:@?D E@ AC@E64E DEC62>D 2?5 C:G6CD]k^Am
kAmr9C:DE6?D6? D2:5 DE@AA:?8 E96 FD6 @7 7:C6 C6E2C52?E H@F=5 “4@?46:G23=J C6DF=E :? 8C62E6C 92C> 7C@> H:=57:C6D — :?4=F5:?8 E@ 9F>2? =:76 2?5 AC@A6CEJ 2?5 E@ E96 6?G:C@?>6?E]” %96 ;F586 D2:5 9:D CF=:?8 H2D =:>:E65 E@ `_ H6DE6C? DE2E6D H96C6 >6>36CD @7 E96 A=2:?E:77’D 8C@FA 2==6865 92C> 7C@> A@==FE:@? :?E@ H2E6CH2JD E92E E96J FD6]k^Am
kAmp7E6C E96 =2HDF:E H2D 7:=65 E96 u@C6DE $6CG:46 2AA=:65 E@ E96 t?G:C@?>6?E2= !C@E64E:@? p86?4J 7@C 2 A6C>:E E92E H@F=5 2==@H :E E@ 4@?E:?F6 FD:?8 C6E2C52?E H:E9@FE 3C62<:?8 E96 =2H] %96 AC@46DD 4@F=5 E2<6 D6G6C2= J62CD]k^Am
kAm$F49 2 A6C>:E 4@F=5 C6BF:C6 E:89E6C C6DEC:4E:@?D @? H96? C6E2C52?E 4@F=5 36 FD65 @C 7@C @77:4:2=D E@ FD6 =6DD\E@I:4 496>:42=D[ D2:5 p?5J $E29= H:E9 u@C6DE $6CG:46 t>A=@J66D 7@C t?G:C@?>6?E2= tE9:4D]k^Am
kAm“xE’D 46CE2:?=J 2 8@@5 7:CDE DE6A[” $E29= D2:5]k^Am
kAmr9C:DE6?D6? @C56C65 7656C2= @77:4:2=D E@ C6A@CE 6G6CJ D:I >@?E9D @? E96:C AC@8C6DD]k^Am
kAmu@C6DE $6CG:46 DA@<6DA6CD@? (256 |F69=9@7 D2:5 E96 286?4J 36=:6G6D C6E2C52?E 42? 36 FD65 “H:E9@FE 4@>AC@>:D:?8 AF3=:4 962=E9 2?5 E96 6?G:C@?>6?E]”k^Am
kAm“%96 u@C6DE $6CG:46 :D H@C<:?8 5:=:86?E=J H:E9 E96 t?G:C@?>6?E2= !C@E64E:@? p86?4J @? 2 86?6C2= A6C>:E 7@C 26C:2==J 56=:G6C65 C6E2C52?E E92E H:== 2==@H FD E@ 4@?E:?F6 FD:?8 H:=57:C6 C6E2C52?E E@ AC@E64E 9@>6D 2?5 4@>>F?:E:6D[” |F69=9@7 D2:5]k^Am
kAmr=:>2E6 492?86[ A6@A=6 >@G:?8 :?E@ 7:C6\AC@?6 2C62D[ 2?5 @G6C8C@H? 7@C6DED 2C6 4C62E:?8 >@C6 42E2DEC@A9:4 >6827:C6D E92E 2C6 92C56C E@ 7:89E]k^Am
kAmp=>@DE `d_ >:==:@? 82==@?D Wdef >:==:@? =:E6CDX @7 7:C6 C6E2C52?E H6C6 5C@AA65 @? }2E:@?2= u@C6DE =2?5D 36EH66? a_`b 2?5 a_aa[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 p8C:4F=EFC6] #6E2C52?E 5C@AD @?E@ 7@C6DED :? r2=:7@C?:2 244@F?E65 7@C chT @7 E96 E@E2= G@=F>6]k^Am
kAmw62=E9 C:D<D E@ 7:C67:89E6CD @C @E96C A6@A=6 H9@ 4@>6 :?E@ 4@?E24E H:E9 7:C6 C6E2C52?E 2C6 4@?D:56C65 =@H[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 2 a_a` C:D< 2DD6DD>6?E]k^Am
kAmqFE E96 496>:42=D 42? 36 92C>7F= E@ D@>6 7:D9[ 7C@8D[ 4CFDE2462?D 2?5 @E96C 2BF2E:4 DA64:6D] p 8@G6C?>6?E DEF5J 7@F?5 >:D2AA=:65 C6E2C52?E 4@F=5 25G6CD6=J 27764E 5@K6?D @7 :>A6C:=65 DA64:6D[ :?4=F5:?8 4C2H7:D9[ DA@EE65 @H=D 2?5 7:D9 DF49 2D D9:?6CD 2?5 DF4<6CD]k^Am
kAmu@C6DE $6CG:46 @77:4:2=D D2:5 E96J 2C6 ECJ:?8 E@ 4@>6 :?E@ 4@>A=:2?46 H:E9 E96 =2H 3J 86EE:?8 2 A@==FE:@? A6C>:E 3FE E92E 4@F=5 E2<6 J62CD]k^Am
kAm%@ <66A DEC62>D 7C@> 86EE:?8 A@==FE65[ @77:4:2=D :? C646?E J62CD 92G6 2G@:565 5C@AD :?D:56 3F776C K@?6D H:E9:? b__ 766E Wha >6E6CDX @7 H2E6CH2JD] #6E2C52?E >2J @?=J 36 2AA=:65 :?D:56 E9@D6 K@?6D H96? 9F>2? =:76 @C AF3=:4 D276EJ :D E9C62E6?65] ~7 a`b :?DE2?46D @7 7:C6 C6E2C52?E =2?5:?8 :? H2E6C 36EH66? a_`a 2?5 a_`h[ `h_ H6C6 244:56?ED 2?5 E96 C6>2:?56C H6C6 ?646DD2CJ E@ D2G6 =:G6D @C AC@A6CEJ[ @77:4:2=D D2:5]k^Am
kAm|2?J 2C62D @7 E96 (6DE6C? &]$] 6IA6C:6?465 962GJ D?@H72==D E9:D A2DE H:?E6C[ 2?5 2D 2 C6DF=E 7:C6 52?86CD 2C6 =@H6C E92? :? C646?E J62CD 24C@DD >F49 @7 E96 C68:@?]k^Am