Prop 1 remains contentious issue

One of the most contentious issues Idahoans will see on their ballot this election is not the presidential or legislative races, but a “yes” or “no” vote on Proposition 1.

Proposition 1 is a citizen-driven ballot initiative that would establish a primary where all candidates are listed on one ballot regardless of party affiliation. The proposition would also create a ranked-choice voting system in the general election, meaning that rather than selecting one candidate for office, voters could rank the candidates in order of preference.

The Idaho Republican Party has strongly opposed Proposition 1, arguing on its website it is “a plot to engineer election results to turn Idaho blue.” However, the initiative has garnered widespread support from other Republican, Independent and Democratic voters across the state who argue the change would allow the 275,000 registered unaffiliated voters in Idaho to vote in the state’s primary elections. Both sides are receiving significant financial backing.

Like candidates, political committees can raise and spend money for their cause. For example, in 2018, two political committees supporting and opposing a ballot initiative to allow video betting for horse racing spent about $6.4 million each, according to campaign finance reports.

While the spending behind Proposition 1 has not yet reached that level, wealthy Idahoans, everyday residents, local politicians and out-of-state groups have spent thousands of dollars to support and oppose Proposition 1.

Idaho for Open Primaries spends $350,000 to support Proposition 1

The group spearheading the financial support for Proposition 1 is Idahoans for Open Primaries, a political action committee supporting the measure.

“The entire campaign was launched by ordinary Idahoans and funded from day one by the contributions of thousands of Idaho citizens, and along the way we’ve raised large contributions as well,” Reclaim Idaho co-founder Luke Mayville told the Idaho Capital Sun. “This campaign is clearly so important that thousands of Idahoans have been willing to contribute to it.”

Since registering with the Idaho Secretary of State’s office in late 2023, the committee has raised $2.8 million, with $1.9 million coming from out-of-state groups, and $900,000 from Idahoans. Its top contributor is the Unite America PAC, a philanthropic venture fund headquartered in Colorado that supports party-neutral reforms that improve representation in elections.

Idahoans for Open Primaries has received contributions from more than 5,000 Idahoans in all 44 counties, and the typical donation runs from $5 to a few hundred dollars, Mayville said.

While it has raised $2.8 million, it has only spent $350,000 on electioneering communications, which includes broadcast and print communications promoting the initiative.

The spending behind the opposition to Idaho’s Proposition 1

Groups opposing Proposition 1 have spent more than $460,000 in electioneering communications this year.

Mayville said he is not surprised to see wealthy donors and special interest groups oppose the open primaries initiative.

“Wealthy donors and special interest groups tend to love closed primaries because closed primary elections are low turnout contests where very few people vote, and it’s much easier to control the outcome with money,” Mayville said.

According to campaign finance reports from the Secretary of State’s Office as of Tuesday, the following political committees have spent significant amounts of money in opposition to Proposition 1.

Idaho Rising, based in Star, has spent $241,000 on broadcast advertising against the initiative. The chairperson of the committee is Idaho House Speaker Mike Moyle, R-Star, who previously told the Sun he would consider working to repeal Proposition 1 if it passed.

Idaho Rising’s top contributions include $125,000 from One Person, One Vote, another Idaho political committee that opposes ranked choice voting; $50,000 from Bayer, an agricultural technology company based in Missouri that has a phosphate mine in Soda Springs; and $50,000 from Melaleuca, an Idaho Falls-based company. Other prominent contributions include $25,000 from Idaho Freedom Foundation board member Doyle Beck and $10,000 from Idaho businessman Larry Williams.

Republicans for Idaho, based in Idaho Falls, has spent $86,000 on billboards across Idaho. Unlike the previously mentioned committee, Republicans for Idaho has two donors, and 98% of its funds come from Melaleuca, or $173,000. The committee did not respond to multiple attempts from the Idaho Capital Sun to learn more about its electioneering efforts.

The Kootenai County Republican Central Committee is another political committee opposing Proposition 1. It has spent at least $9,500 in advertisements, newspapers and other communications opposing the initiative.

Brent Regan, the chairman of the Kootenai County Republican Central Committee, told the Idaho Capital Sun the proposition would cost his county nearly $4 million dollars, citing a July letter from the Idaho Secretary of State to the Idaho Legislature that said the proposition would cost the state at least $25 million to $40 million if the state needs to replace its vote tabulation systems. Idahoans for Open Primaries has said that the state would not have to spend that much because software is available to update Idaho’s current system.

“We are getting many requests from citizens for signs and are trying to keep up with the demand,” Regan said in an email about the committee’s efforts opposing Proposition 1.

Additionally, the Bonneville County Republican Central Committee has also spent about $1,800 on advertisements in opposition to the proposition.

Who else is opposing Proposition 1?

There are other groups who are opposing Proposition 1 through social media and signs, but they have not disclosed the specific details of how much they’ve spent to oppose the initiative.

Across Idaho, there are signs funded by the Idaho Republican Party saying “Vote No to Prop. 1” and “Don’t Californicate Idaho’s elections.” It is unclear how much the party has spent on these signs, since the party has not reported the exact costs associated with the signs to the Idaho Secretary of State.

A sign paid for by the Idaho Republican State Central Committee at the intersection of Eagle Road and Fairview Avenue in Meridian encourages Idahoans to vote no on Proposition 1. (Christina Lords/Idaho Capital Sun)

The Idaho Republican Party did not respond to questions from the Idaho Capital Sun for more details about how many signs it purchased and how much was spent. In an email update Oct. 8, the Idaho Republican Party said it still had “a large amount” of signs left.

Other groups who have worked to oppose Proposition 1 include Secure Idaho Elections and One Person, One Vote – both of which have websites dedicated to opposing ranked choice voting.

Secure Idaho Elections is not registered as a political committee and does not have data available about its spending in the Idaho Secretary of State’s campaign finance portal.

Secure Idaho Elections’ cofounder, Michael Angiletta, told the Sun in an email the organization is a 501(c)4, and its goal is to promote voter education and make state elections more secure. It has small individual donors, and no out-of-state or PAC funding, he said.

One Person, One Vote, on the other hand, is a registered political committee. Its chairman is Idaho House Representative Josh Tanner, R-Eagle.

Its top contributions include $125,000 from Idaho businessman Larry Williams, $10,000 from Don Hubble, the founder of housing developer Hubble Homes, and $5,000 from the Avimor Development. While the committee has not yet reported expenses in the Idaho Secretary of State’s campaign finance portal, records show it has given $125,000 to the previously mentioned committee Idaho Rising.

One Person, One Vote could not be reached for comment.

Idaho Capital Sun is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Idaho Capital Sun maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Christina Lords for questions: info@idahocapitalsun.com. Follow Idaho Capital Sun on Facebook and X.